Sunday, October 19, 2025

Shadow Ticket (2025) by Thomas Pynchon

 


My first encounter with the work of Thomas Pynchon came in high school when for some uncertain reason I decided to start reading Mason & Dixon—perhaps having google searched for the best books of 1997, because it’s my birthyear, and deciding this one looked the most interesting—which after making it a few hundred pages or so in I for some other uncertain reason stopped reading and never did finish—perhaps the simple result of life’s frictions slowing down the inertia of my progress, rather than any particular dissatisfaction. Who knows; I was young. My next encounter came in my first post-college summer, the summer of Covid, the summer of 2020, this time with more foreknowledge of what I was getting into and indeed who Thomas Pynchon even was, when I picked up Gravity’s Rainbow as my nighttime reading. With free time galore and the mental space provided by a slowed-down world, I had disciplined myself into dedicating a full hour to reading fiction before bed every night, and at a rate of about 30 per I’d swept through all 700-some pages in what was probably my quickest journey through a book of that size in my adult life. But here’s the question: did I understand any of it? I’d have to answer that with a qualified No. Skimming the book’s Wikipedia page the other day, I didn’t recognize much that I actually comprehended at the time of reading, even things as simple as when and where the book supposedly “took place.” No matter. I’m sure I’ll read it again some day down the line, older and wiser and all that, and if I failed at grasping some pretty fundamental facets of it I still went away with whatever edification comes from the simple act of having spent so many hours in a book/world so clearly the work of a skilled, substantive, stylish author. I breezed through The Crying of Lot 49 last summer as a short palette cleanser after a six month trek through War and Peace, and then read Vineland earlier this year—you wouldn’t believe me if I tried to claim that it largely wasn’t prompted by the then-upcoming Paul Thomas Anderson movie, so I won’t. I enjoyed both of these books, and I “understood” them, at least on a logistical level, more than those Pynchons previous. The announcement of a new Pynchon novel in Shadow Ticket felt serendipitous on multiple personal levels. I’d acquainted myself with his work enough for this to be the first real instance of “anticipation for a new fiction publication” I’d felt since, I don’t know, whatever popular adult fiction I’d been interested in as a teenager (which I’d been literarily reared on via my dad); the preceding decade had mostly been spent reading “classic” literary fiction, your Dostoevskys & Hawthornes & such (in whatever time I could find outside of my obsessive film viewing schedule of course); and I’d only read one novel published in the 2020s up to this point (Michel Houellebecq’s great Annihilation). Secondly, as the work of an author in his late 80s, the late style associations brought by a new Pynchon book came perfectly timed with my work on my book about late style—any time I spent reading Shadow Ticket could be chalked up as research, making myself feel slightly better about trading progress in my own work for pleasure in someone else’s, and would generally be a thematically and therefore aesthetically appropriate addition to my life at this point in time. (If you’re out of the loop, check my last blog post for details, but my book Late Style in Film is still on track to arrive sometime early next year.) Lastly, Shadow Ticket wasn’t to be just a Thomas Pynchon book, but a Thomas Pynchon book set in Milwaukee. As a southeastern Wisconsin lifer, this brought me no small amount of pride, and to see my very own hometown—Waukesha, which lies about 15 miles west of Milwaukee, to get personal for a second—mentioned more than once is enough to be one of those “sorry, this is the only thing I’m gonna be talking about for the next week” kind of things that I will treasure to the point of being kind of sad that there aren’t actually that many people in my local life familiar enough with Pynchon for the coolness of this to even register if I told them about it. I’m less of a local historian than I’d like to be, but everything about Pynchon’s evocation of 1930s Milwaukee and the beer & cheese-ness of it all is just catnip to me, as are the hilarious Pynchonian tangents related to it (from Chapter 13: “Does cheese, considered as a living entity, also possess consciousness?”). For the record, if you’re interested, here is a list I kept of every Wisconsin city mentioned in the book: Baraboo, Delafield, Grafton, Green Bay, Kenosha, Kewaunee, Madison, Milwaukee, Oconomowoc, Oshkosh, Racine, Sheboygan, Two Rivers, Waukesha, Waupun, Wauwatosa, West Allis, and Wonewoc. Shadow Ticket is surely being proclaimed “slight” by certain critics and readers by virtue of it’s sub-300 page count and seeming lack of grand literary pretentions beyond its simple quasi-metaphysical detective plot, but man if I didn’t thoroughly enjoy reading this more than almost anything in recent memory. The ‘30s setting lets Pynchon go crazy inventing dialogue that’s like a more literarily tangled version of pre-Code Hollywood existentialism, and the way he wields language in general is just a line-by-line treat. He does this thing with vernacular phrases where he’ll throw in little clauses, sometimes offset by commas sometimes not, that shake up a sentence and keep everything just humorously off-balance enough to keep the writing from ever being anything less than alive. It’s very funny without ever diffusing the stakes—to the degree that the actual stakes can be ascertained, an aspect of the book that makes it slippery and mysterious and, again, very funny. If I had to nail down one of Pynchon’s main themes, it would simply be that History is Weird, and that living through it is even weirder. Weird as in funny but also concerning, confusing, and so forth (a phrase Pynchon never gets tired of appending to the end of sentences or paragraphs in Shadow Ticket, and which I never got tired of enjoying the deployment of.) Accusing Pynchon of turning a blind eye to the (very Pynchonian, you know) present day for a tale of conspiracy and confusion in 1932 instead is not just very funny but also to miss the fact that the world has always been Pynchonian: 18th-century early America was Pynchonian, WWII-era Europe was Pynchonian, ‘60s & ‘80s California was Pynchonian, 1930s Milwaukee and pre-WWII Europe was Pynchonian, and, yes, the present day is rather Pynchonian. I’d even argue that Shadow Ticket is not inconsequential to present-day concerns at all, but in fact might be useful for articulating and therefore navigating whatever proto-fascist malaise you might feel we are currently living under. But I leave all that for someone who has more time to get into it, happy just that I could contribute even this casual little piece to the pile of thought in the world and—even though I have been hard at work this year, I promise—to at least get one blogpost up so it doesn’t look like I had a totally blank 2025.

Shadow Ticket (2025) by Thomas Pynchon

  My first encounter with the work of Thomas Pynchon came in high school when for some uncertain reason I decided to start reading Mason ...